What to Do After a Denied Workers’ Comp Claim in Vermont

October 7, 2025

By Erin Barker

Workers’ comp is designed to help you stay afloat when you’ve been injured on the job, so what do you do if your claim is denied? This kind of situation is understandably upsetting, but don’t lose your cool. You have options, so take a moment to learn what to do after a denied workers’ comp claim in Vermont, and how Shillen, Mackall, Seldon, and Spicer can help you do it.

Understanding Why Your Workers’ Comp Claim Was Denied

Dealing with a denied workers’ compensation claim can be challenging, but understanding the reason for the denial is the first step toward resolving it. Common reasons for denial include not having enough evidence to back up your injury claim, missing deadlines for reporting the injury, or not filing paperwork on time. Sometimes, inconsistencies in medical records or doubts about whether the injury is work-related can also cause issues.

Pinpointing the exact reasons for the denial helps in crafting a solid appeal. By addressing these specific issues, you can build a stronger case to challenge the decision and work towards getting the benefits you deserve.

Steps to Take After a Workers’ Comp Claim Denial

Facing a workers’ compensation denial can be overwhelming, but taking the right steps promptly can significantly affect the outcome. Here’s how to navigate the process effectively:

1. Review the Denial Letter

Examine the denial letter from your employer’s insurance company to understand why your claim was denied, with common reasons being insufficient medical evidence or procedural mistakes. Pay close attention to any deadlines, as missing them can jeopardize your appeal. Check for any missing documents that may have resulted in the denial, as these will be crucial for your appeal.

2. Gather Additional Evidence

Once you understand the denial reasons, focus on collecting more evidence to support your case. This could involve obtaining detailed medical records, securing statements from colleagues who witnessed the incident, or consulting medical experts about your condition. Organize this evidence carefully, focusing on creating a clear timeline of events and a well-compiled set of documents to use in your appeal.

3. File an Appeal

In Vermont, filing an appeal involves specific steps and deadlines that must be met to improve the chances of success. Begin by completing the necessary forms, available on the Vermont Department of Labor’s website. Ensure all paperwork is accurate and submitted on time, as missing deadlines can result in automatic dismissal.

Legal Assistance: Increasing Your Chances of Winning an Appeal

Navigating the appeals process can be challenging, and professional legal help can be invaluable. An experienced lawyer can clarify the complexities of your case and enhance your chances of success. They can identify the strengths and weaknesses of your case, ensuring all evidence is presented effectively.

Why Choose Shillen, Mackall, Seldon, and Spicer?

For workers’ compensation appeals, Shillen, Mackall, Seldon, and Spicer offer a wealth of experience and a strong track record of success. We’re an experienced law firm in Vermont specializing in workers’ compensation cases, among other areas. Our expertise in handling complex cases enables us to guide you through the appeals process, helping you challenge claim denials and secure the benefits you need.

Appeal a Workers’ Comp Denial and Get the Compensation You Deserve

If your workers’ compensation claim has been denied, you’ll want to act fast. Understanding the reasons for the denial, gathering appropriate evidence, and filing a timely appeal are essential steps to turn things around. Professional legal support can significantly boost your chances of success, as well, helping you navigate the system with confidence.
If your workers’ comp claim has been denied, consider reaching out for expert legal assistance. Contact us at Shillen, Mackall, Seldon, and Spicer to get started on your appeal and finally receive the compensation you deserve.

Image credit: // Shutterstock // sebra

Categories